The American Planning Association has published “Planning for Uncertainty with Climate Adaptation Pathways,” the first in its new PAS Practical Guidance: Planning in Action series. Integral principal Melissa May, AICP, is lead author the guide with Alice McLean, AICP, of SSFM International. Integral’s David Revell, Ph.D., and Matthew Jamieson contributed technical review and case studies drawn from Integral’s coastal resilience work.
Planning for a future we can’t predict
Communities everywhere are being asked to plan for sea level rise and other climate risks without knowing exactly how much change is coming, or how fast. At the same time, many planning, permitting, and funding decisions are made on short time horizons, even though the buildings, roads, and utilities that are approved may be in place for 50 years or more. That longevity carries an obligation to acknowledge long-term climate risks and build them into today’s planning and investment decisions.
What are adaptation pathways?
Adaptation pathways give communities a practical way forward. Rather than betting on a single strategy or a single forecast, a pathway lays out a phased, flexible series of actions, so communities can act now, keep future options open, and know when it’s time to change course.
Each action is tied to observable conditions, such as how often a road floods or how far a shoreline has eroded. These conditions act as triggers that signal when to start funding and permitting the next action, so it is ready before a critical failure point is reached.
The process of developing a pathway matters as much as the result. It builds community alignment around goals, trade-offs, and when to change course, drawing on technical analysis and climate science as well as local and indigenous knowledge and lived experience.
What’s inside the guide
Written for planners, the guide supports communities with examples and best practices for developing pathways. It shows how pathways connect long-term resilience goals to near-term decisions on land use, infrastructure, funding, and policy, and it covers the full process, from setting goals and acceptable risk levels through monitoring and budgeting. Readers will find:
- Action steps for getting started
- A sample pathway for a coastal road
- Case studies from Integral projects in Santa Cruz, California, and Maui, Hawaiʻi
- Examples of adaptation planning and policy from across the country
Lessons from the field: Santa Cruz and Maui
Two case studies from Integral’s coastal resilience work show how pathways play out in real places:
- West Cliff Drive, Santa Cruz, California: pathways for four segments of a coastal roadway, with lessons learned from a post-disaster scenario
- Hoaloha Park, Maui, Hawaiʻi: the first sea level rise adaptation plan for a Maui County beach park, built around canoe paddling, cultural resources, and the needs of park users
Part of a growing national conversation
The guide also highlights adaptation planning and policy work happening across the country, including California’s statewide sea level rise guidance, the San Francisco Bay Area’s Regional Shoreline Adaptation Plan, Miami Beach’s Sea Level Rise Adaptation Plan, and New York City’s Climate Resiliency Design Guidelines. In Hawaiʻi, it features efforts ranging from One Water Honolulu to Maui County’s beach park adaptation plans, along with the state’s adaptation pathway legislation and a statewide study on managed retreat.
APA members can download the guide here:
Questions about applying adaptation pathways to your community, asset, or infrastructure system? Contact our coastal resilience experts:
- Melissa May, AICP: mmay@integral-corp.com
- David Revell, Ph.D.: drevell@integral-corp.com